lause |
Making Move?
(Y/N) |
Stances |
| Move 1, "Establish a Territory ," Introduction 1 (*green = Stance Keywords) |
|
| 1 |
(Y) generalization of what trust is.
|
Non Argumentative |
Trust is central to human relations of all kinds.
|
| 2 |
(N) support C1 |
Non Argumentative: to state fact |
We trust our parents, our friends, our teachers, and so on.
|
| 3 |
(N) support C1 |
High Argumentative: to proclaim |
We even trust people more generally, people we have never met, |
| 3.1 |
(N) support C1 |
Non Argumentative: to state fact |
as we go about our daily lives. |
| 4 |
(N) support C1 |
Non Argumentative: to state fact |
We trust our doctor to prescribe the right medications. |
| 5 |
(N) support C1 |
Non Argumentative: to state fact |
We trust people on the street to provide us with accurate directions |
| 6 |
(N) support C1 |
Tentative: to indicate a circumstance |
when we are lost. |
| 7 |
(N) support C1 |
Non Argumentative: to state fact |
We trust our teachers to let us know when we are doing well or poorly in school. |
| 8 |
(N) support C1 |
Tentative: to hypothesize |
The reasons, moreover, that we extend trust to others appear to be as wide-ranging as the situations in which we decide to trust.
|
| 9 |
(N) support C1 |
Non Argumentative: to state fact |
We trust people |
| 9.1 |
(N) support C1 |
Non Argumentative: to state fact |
because our intuition tells us they are trustworthy; |
| 9.2 |
(N) support C1 |
Non Argumentative: to state fact |
we think of our intuition as guiding us, for example, |
| 9.3 |
(N) support C1 |
Tentative: to indicate a circumstance |
when we ask a stranger to watch our luggage |
| 9.4 |
(N) support C1 |
Tentative: to indicate a circumstance |
when we use the washroom in the train station. |
| 10 |
(N) support C1 |
Non Argumentative: to state fact |
We trust experts |
| 10.1 |
(N) support C1 |
Non Argumentative: to state fact |
because they have credentials we recognise; |
| 10.2 |
(N) support C1 |
Med Argumentative: to suggest high possibility |
health and legal professionals often post their diplomas where patients and clients can see them, so as to give them information on which they can base their trust. |
| 11 |
(N) support C1 |
Non Argumentative: to state fact |
We trust others |
| 11.1 |
(N) support C1 |
Non Argumentative: to state fact |
because we have something important in common; |
| 11.2 |
(N) support C1 |
Med Argumentative: to suggest high possibility |
members of ethnocultural groups often extend trust to each other more easily than they do to outsiders. |
| 12 |
(Y) increasing specificity about what "trust" is |
Non Argumentative |
In these situations, trust is an element of human relations – |
| 12.1 |
(Y) increasing specificity about what "trust" is |
Non Argumentative |
trust is something that one person extends to and receives from another – which contains both attitudinal and behavioural elements. |
| 13 |
(N) support C12 |
Tentative: to suggest a future condition/situation |
A trusting person will do something and with a particular attitude, namely, a willingness to put herself in vulnerability with respect to another person (Baier, 1986, pp. 234–40).
|
| 14 |
(N) support C12 |
Tentative: to indicate a circumstance |
When we trust someone, |
| 14.1 |
(N) support C12 |
Non Argumentative: to state fact |
we become vulnerable to the possibility of disappointment or betrayal. |
| 15 |
(N) support C12 |
Med Argumentative: to suggest higher possibility of |
Because we cannot know whether a person who is trusted will fulfil this trust (O'Neill, 2002b, p. 6) |
| 15.1 |
(N) support C12 |
Non Argumentative: to state fact |
– the risk of disappointment is inherent in the concept of trust (Warren, 1999a, p. 311). |
| 16 |
(N) support C12 |
High Argumentative: to proclaim |
Trust, as described in this way, is clearly a part of our everyday lives. |
